Cities are often seen as sites of emancipation and freedom for women, as compared to the social restrictions of the village and the hard manual labour of working on the farm. Small cities might not offer the level of freedoms women experience in the metropolis, they do, however, create specific opportunities for young women to access non-farm work. A gender inclusive planning and governance framework is urgently needed to leverage the potential for improving women's work outcomes in these places.
This blog is part of a series sharing findings from a research initiative of the JustJobs Network and the Centre for Policy Research that examined small cities in India and Indonesia. Read the introductory blog here.
Cities are often seen as sites of emancipation and freedom for women, as compared to the social restrictions of the village and the hard manual labour of working on the farm. Indeed, we find that all our case cities are attractive destinations for young women to be able to pursue opportunities to study and work while being close to their places of origin. Like many other south-east Asian contexts, the cluster of export-oriented manufacturing firms in Semarang Regency, Indonesia has triggered a wave of female migration; in fact, 76 percent of the women we surveyed in the city worked in factories. Kupang and Mangalore offer women work in service occupations like retail and education, while Kishangarh is an important hub for female education in its region.
Notions of ‘women’s work’ prevail in many of these occupations: that women have ‘nimble fingers’ is a key premise in garment production in Semarang Regency, the notion of care work as feminine work drives the predominance of nursing and domestic work in Mangalore, and in Kishangarh, women’s work outside the home is deeply stigmatized and they are often stuck doing cleaning and sweeping work or home-based tasks like stitching. These notions are often a means to keep women in low wage, precarious jobs with hard working conditions and negligible social protection. That the growth of the service sector has created opportunities for women to work in retail, education and hospitality is surely a good sign. However here too, they are often stuck, with slim chances of promotions and wage increases. Moreover, conditions of exploitation often persist; for example, in Kupang, young women working in retail establishments often live on the premises, and though employers might provide food and lodging, they also monitor their movements and expect long hours of work without additional remuneration.
Access to work in small cities is facilitated by kinship networks based on religion, caste and ethnicity and women have to navigate these in addition to gender biases. Our qualitative fieldwork indicates that women rely on intra-household negotiations and negotiate what Kandiyoti has famously called the “patriarchal bargain”, which pushes against convention and yet remains within its bounds. For instance, working in Kupang helps women delay marriage and in Semarang Regency, women often find spouses in the city, thus combining incomes for enhanced prosperity. In Kishangarh’s intensely conservative milieu, women use academic achievements as a way to delay marriage and opt to work in spaces their families consider ‘safe’, e.g. within the home, in family enterprises or by starting home-based businesses.
Our research finds some supporting institutions and practices in small cities address some of the challenges working women face. In Semarang Regency, migrant women rely on kosts, boarding houses where safe, affordable accommodation is bundled with services. They also have better access to the formal banking system and are more likely to be members of unions, as compared to their male counterparts. Efficient and safe transportation systems – paratransit in Semarang Regency and private buses in Mangalore – improve mobility within the city as well.
Overall, while small cities might not offer the level of freedoms women experience in the metropolis, they do create specific opportunities for young women to access non-farm work. And while some spontaneous initiatives might exist to facilitate opportunities for women, a gender inclusive planning and governance framework is urgently needed to leverage the potential for improving women’s work outcomes in these places.
JJN’s Sabina Dewan writes on the expanding e-commerce ecosystem in India and its effect on MSMEs of the country. From the perspective of micro, small and medium enterprises, that are dealing with tech disruptions to stay in business and the 111 million jobs they support, she calls for appropriate and effective regulations to enable more inclusive growth of e-commerce.
While tech platforms have eased our lives, too little attention is paid to a growing inequity. Capital gets to multiply, but gig workers are left at a disadvantage as they’re not treated as employees and lack labour protection under the law. This capital-labour imbalance needs to be addressed.
As global labour markets continue to undergo transition induced by rapid technological advancement and climate change, there is not enough research that captures the diverse experiences of the Global South. The FutureWORKS Collective, funded by IDRC Canada, is a consortium of research organisations that will fill this lacuna. The JustJobs Network is proud to be the coordinator of this initiative that underscores the urgency of adapting research and policies to the realities of the Global South.
Bihar’s unconventional urbanisation is not characterised by the development of industrial hubs that generally characterise the process of urbanisation. Despite being famous for its out-migration, Bihar is experiencing something that the author describes as “urbanisation from within” i.e. the natural growth and densification of small towns and villages, increased population density and a shift from agriculture to non-farm activities. This article points out challenges in this form of urbanisation and suggests changes that will transform these urbanising villages into centers of job-rich economic development.
As the Union Government of India presents its interim budget, Sabina Dewan reviews the state of the country's labour market, and related policies. Theincrease in overall labour force participation is largely driven by an increase in rural female labour force participation, and comes against a backdrop of heighted rural distress with a consistent decline in inflation-adjusted real wages over the last five years. In light of shifting demographics, technological upheaval, climate change, and the pandemic, she makes the case for a robust policy response codified in a national employment strategy that can foster an ecosystem conducive to the growth of good jobs.
A government initiative to promote conservation and build climate resilience, the GREEN Meghalaya scheme is based on the payment for ecosystems model (PES). This article introduces the PES model and poses inquiries about its operation and implementation, especially against the changing landscape of forest conservation in India.
In the wake of the ongoing climate crises, what would energy transition mean for economies and labour markets around the world? Sabina Dewan discusses how developing countries like India, with large and growing youth populations, are facing immense pressure to manage energy transition which will restructure labour markets and have significant economic, political and social ramifications. She presents the interlinkages and ripple effects of a transition to geener energy alternates on migration patterns, household income structures, skilling requirements and job creation.
The article highlights challenges transgender individuals encounter in workplaces and
society. It emphasises holistic recognition by linking food, shelter, and employment for inclusive
efforts in their livelihoods.
The newly enacted law to reserve one-third seats for women in the Lok Sabha and state legislatures could advance gender equality in India. Certain conditions however need to be met to ensure that numerical representation translates to substantive representation.
The success of UWEI and MUKTA, Odisha’s initiatives to curb pandemic-induced urban employment could well be the blueprint for a National Urban Employment Guarantee Act that emphasizes worker security, community involvement and a gender-inclusive design.
The building and construction sector in India is marred with inherent contradictions – it is at once an employment generator and a highly polluting sector. It stresses the question: How do we balance human needs without compromising earth systems?
Despite good intentions, much in the new Rajasthan gig workers act is built on weak foundations, which will make it difficult to implement. This makes it unlikely that the workers will actually get what they deserve.